Sundae Cafe at Tybee

Brent gaffey

4 out of 5 stars★★★★☆

This place was a mixed bag. It is located in a small strip mall that is connected to a gas station, located on the expensive island of Tybee Island. Obviously the prices are gonna be inflated, which is expected. This place left me yearning for more, could be that my in-laws gassed it up so much that i expected to be served food on gold plates. The interior was a bit dark and felt dingy. The food is mostly locally sourced and it is advertised on the menu as such. For the prices I expect good food, and I think every single person made at least 1 gripe about something on their plate. It was good, but i felt something to be desired in almost everything we ate. I enjoyed myself and my company, i think id give it one more chance.

N B

5 out of 5 stars★★★★★

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️Soooooo... Im sorry if the restaurant may not like me sharing this... BUT to tell the reason I ate from Sundae's.... We REALLY needed to use the restroom and asked to buy something to be allowed to use a cleaner restroom, than the one outside. So mad I didn't get his name, but the bartender allowed us to use it without purchasing... THANK YOU, YOU'RE SOOO AWESOME❤️❤️🙏🏽🙏🏽. When finished I insisted on purchasing in 'appreciation'. I wanted fish and he suggested the blackened fl and suggested sides as well... (YES I'M ABOUT TO BE EXTRA AS HECK ABOUT THE FOOD LOL ...but seriously) THAT WAS SOME OF THE BEST FOOD I HAVE HAD IN A WHILE.. the fish was DELICIOUS and that pimento squash side (not sure of the exact name) WAS ABSOLUTELY AMAZING... DONT YOU EVER GO THERE AND NOT TRY IT‼️‼️‼️ My only thing is, although the mac and cheese was also great, I wouldn't order it along with the pimento squash side to allow for something else without cheese... Im soooo happy I purchased food there "in appreciation " lol... 10 outta 10 dammit‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️

May Ree

5 out of 5 stars★★★★★

Started off dinner with perfectly cooked fried green tomatoes topped with feta & balsamic/apricot spread.  Main course was perfectly cooked pistachio tuna with wasabi aioli and twice baked skillet potatoes w/cheese & bacon & roasted hot honey carrots. Dessert was a key lime pie and banana pudding cheesecake both were very sweet and delicious this was an amazing dinner literally the best meal that I have had on the island. 

Miles Peck

5 out of 5 stars★★★★★

Wow; that is all I had to say leaving the Sundae Cafe. Seriously, some of the most exceptional food I have had in YEARS. We started with complementary homemade biscuits and peach jam, which were warm, delicious and the jam I would’ve taken home in a jar if I could’ve. The crab stuffed flounder was to die for, like completely blew my mind, the hot honey jerk shrimp was potentially my favorite shrimp I’ve had and the scallops were cooked beautifully, and tasted incredibly fresh and delicious. For dessert, we had a chocolate cake with fudge icing, which was phenomenal. Our server, Crystal, was a total doll, and the atmosphere was wonderful, especially given that this is located next to a damn liquor store and corner store! We will absolutely be back, and would give this 6 stars if we could. Don’t miss this gem while on Tybee! A place truly worth the price of admission.

Armon Taclan 808

4 out of 5 stars★★★★☆

The place has a nice refine vibe to it. My waiter/bartender Doug was cool. Food was alright... I give it a 4 out of 5. Steak was over cooked in my opinion as I ordered a medium rare and came out as a medium to medium well... Slight pink so it came out dry.... The scallops was great and mash potatoes was good. The fried oysters was delicious but was looking for some raw oysters and they didn't have.